Feb. 09, 2010




















   

    qanda_articles_title.gif (8361 bytes)

Steroids and Supplements Still a Safety Issue
   
Not long ago young athletes began using anabolic steroids to increase muscle size while working out. They seemed effective until some professional athletes and high profile people starting showing side effects. NFL star Lyle Alzado developed a brain tumor and spoke out against the use of steroids before he died. Soon steroids were banned from Olympic competition. When other side effects began appearing in the medical literature, the recreational use of steroids dramatically decreased.

It did not take long for young athletes to start looking for other products to give them an "edge." They tried several substances, such as bee pollen carnitine and chromium, without success. Soon a new product - creatine - appeared in gyms and high school locker rooms. Touted as the "safe steroid," the use of creatine supplements was promoted as a powerful energy source for muscles.

To understand why some believe creatine works, a short course in biochemistry is needed. Energy is burned during exercise and sport activities. The primary source of the muscle’s energy during exercise and sporting events is a compound called adenosine triphosphate, or ATP. Creatine helps regenerate the ATP our bodies use to power muscle contractions during activity bursts.

Creatine is an amino acid naturally made in the liver and pancreas, stored in the muscle, and naturally found in milk, meat and fish. The daily requirement of creatine is about two grams. The theory by some trainers and coaches is that if by saturating muscles with creatine athletes will increase the muscle's creatine stores. Athletes will then be able to regenerate ATP faster and have more energy and less exhaustion. According to a study in July's Journal of the American Dietetic Association, weight lifters who took supplementary creatine could do more powerful jump squats and more bench-press repetitions because their ATP was replenished faster.

Word quickly spread that creatine was safe and effective since it seemed to increased muscle strength and accelerated the muscle’s recovery time between bouts of intense exercise. Therefore, creatine may work by allowing athletes to work out harder. Creatine does nothing by itself without exercise.

Once the use of creatine became more widespread, doctors and trainers began seeing side effects. The most common reason young athletes stop using the product is severe diarrhea and gastric distress. Many athletes became predisposed to cramping and dehydration (even those promoting creatine supplements encourage hydration). More scientific studies were done that showed positive effects in the exercise laboratory, but no positive effects with athletes in competition. Respected members of the sports medicine community have reported muscle tears in athletes on creatine. Furthermore, taking more than five grams per day of creatine was associated with kidney and liver inflammation.

Since studies on creatine loading are less than a decade old, it is still unknown what long term effects the extra creatine will have. Some researchers fear that, with the amount of extra creatine ingested through supplements, the body might stop producing it. Furthermore, supplements like creatine are not regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Therefore, what is on the label may have nothing to do with what is inside the package.

"I do not recommend creatine supplementation for anyone under the age of 16," commented St. Petersburg, Fla., orthopaedic surgeon Michael J. Smith, MD. "Unfortunately, the only way we will find out if there are any negative effects of creatine is its long term use. We might find out the hard way that it is dangerous," added Dr. Smith. Should parents find out that their older teenager is using the supplement, Dr. Smith recommends that they take no more than five grams per day. The concern many pediatricians have is the thinking of many student athletes that "if a little is good, more is better." Therefore, there is a danger that adolescents using creatine might take much more than the recommended dose on the label.

In addition, the use of creatine with its possible side effects is another example of the "win at all costs" attitude that has become much too prevalent in today’s sport’s oriented society. We have already seen too many overuse injuries in children. Will we now start having more permanent body damage from consuming abnormal quantities of supplements?

For more information, check out these Web sites:

  • National Institute on Drug Abuse
  • National Institute on Drug Abuse for Teens


    Reviewed 3-27-07

    Do you have a question?

    As a reminder, this information should not be relied on as medical advice and is not intended to replace the advice of your doctor. Please read our full .

  • Last Updated
    Feb. 09, 2010
    Privacy Statement | Disclaimer | Advertise on TeenGrowth
     
    Copyright © 1999-2010, KG Investments, LLC







     
    Web Design by Gecko Media
    Tampa, Florida Pediatricians
    Pediatric Health Care Alliance